Youngtimer Collectibles: Why the ’90s Icons Are Heating Up
Behind the Hype
The term youngtimer is gaining real traction in collector circles—and for good reason. As models from the 1980s and ’90s hit the 25-to-40-year mark, they’re entering the sweet spot of nostalgia, affordability, and driving enjoyment—especially rarer, driver-focused models like the BMW E39 M5 and the Toyota Supra Mk IV.
BMW E39 M5 – A V8 Sedan That Changed the Game
Engineering pedigree: Produced from 1999–2003, the E39 M5 was the first M5 powered by a high-revving 4.9-L naturally aspirated V8 paired with a 6-speed manual—reviving purist performance in a four-door sedan
Auction highlights:
BMW E39 M5
A 2002 BMW M5, labeled "Original & Highly Original" with a 6-speed manual and under 10,000 miles, is currently listed for $139,990 in Cincinnati, Ohio.
A 2000 BMW M5, also manual and in similarly original condition, is available in Glen Cove, New York—priced at $59,995.
In Arizona (Mesa), another 2000 manual M5 is listed for $62,500.
Earlier in August, a 2003 BMW M5 Sedan with just over 10,800 miles and some tasteful modifications was priced at $155,990 in Cincinnati.
One of the rare Oxford Green examples, with just ~25,000 miles and caramel leather, fetched over $100,000 when it crossed the block in April 2024
A “barn-find” E39 M5 surfaced from a California garage—first spotted by Silver Arrow Cars. The trio including an E39 M5 with just 4,000 miles could collectively bring over $1 million—but the M5 has already sold privately
These listings illustrate a strong range in values—depending on model year, mileage, originality, and location—typically spanning $60,000 to $160,000 for clean, driver-focused examples.
Toyota Supra Mk IV (A80, 4th Gen) — JDM Legend on the Move
According to classic.com, the lowest recorded sale price for a 4th-generation Supra (A80) is $25,250 for a 1993 Supra RZ—sold on August 18, 2025.
Meanwhile, the highest recorded sale price for this gen was a staggering $550,000 for the actual “Fast & Furious” movie car—a sale that took place June 19, 2021.
These figures highlight just how wide the value spectrum is for Mk IV Supras—ranging from modestly priced daily drivers to extremely high premiums for iconic, provenance-laden specimens.
Recent sales:
A 1994 Mk IV Turbo, sold online in August 2025, closed at $60,615
A well-preserved 1991 Supra 3.0i (earlier generation) with 60k miles was estimated at £14,000–16,000 (~ $18k–$20k) in a March 2025 Charterhouse auction
Earlier ’90s examples continue to show stable interest at UK and US auctions, with broad ranges depending on condition and spec
Why the Collectibility Curve Is Rising
• Auctions fuel awareness: Not only do high-profile sales stir excitement, but consistent mid-range sales validate the market trajectory.
• Driver-first design: Both cars favor engaging, analog experiences—manual gearboxes, visceral engines, and a lack of intrusive electronics.
• Cultural cachet: The Supra’s cinematic fame, coupled with the E39’s appreciation among enthusiasts, makes them evergreen in both spec sheets and conversations.
Wrap-Up
The BMW E39 M5 and Toyota Supra Mk IV represent the rising wave of youngtimer desirability—cars that blend driver engagement, limited supply, and cultural legacy. Whether you're a nostalgia hunter or future-focused collector, these models are shaping the market now—and in the years ahead.
Thanks for reading this edition of ‘The Driver’s Brief.’ If you are selling, buying, or would like to find out more about our services, use the contact button below.
